Menu

Food and Drink Menu

Explore appetizers, tacos, soups, entrees, handhelds, salads, sides, and happy hour specials at The Rusty Cup Bar and Grill.

Appetizers

  • CALAMARI — $17 — Battered and served with marinara sauce
  • MAHI BITES — $15 — Fried, grilled or blackened with Thai sauce
  • WINGS — $15 — 8 bone-in wings tossed in choice of sauce and served with bleu cheese. Boneless wings $14. Flavors: BBQ, Old Bay, Hot Honey Old Bay, Garlic Buffalo, Hot, Garlic Parm, Thai Chili and Teriyaki
  • AHI TUNA — $22 — Lightly blackened, rare, sliced ahi tuna, served with seaweed & avocado with Cusabi & Old Time Mustard
  • TUNA NACHOS — $22 — Rare, diced ahi tuna, with seaweed salad atop wonton chips and drizzled with sriracha ranch & sweet chili sauce
  • CHICKEN TENDERS — $15 — Hand battered and served with choice of sauce (try tossing in a sauce)
  • CHICKEN QUESADILLA — $15 — Diced jerk chicken, jalapenos & shredded cheddar
  • RUSTY NACHOS — $18 — Salted tortilla chips topped with melted cheese, fresh pico, black bean corn salsa, ground beef or grilled chicken and served with sour cream
  • LOADED FRIES — $13 — Our hand-cut fries topped with melted Cooper Sharp sauce, bacon & ranch drizzle
  • BUFFALO CHICKEN DIP — $16 — Served with tortilla chips
  • STEAMED SHRIMP — 1lb $25 / 1/2lb $17 — Seasoned with Old Bay and served with Onions & Potatoes
  • OYSTERS — $2 each — Ask about our salts and sweets, served on the half shell by half dozen or dozen

Tacos

  • TUNA TACOS (3) — $18 — Our tuna nachos as tacos
  • VEGETARIAN TACOS (3) — $18 — Black bean corn salsa, avocado, grilled mushrooms, pickled cabbage, and avocado lime sauce with a side of pico
  • SHRIMP, MAHI, OR CHICKEN TACOS (3) — $18 — Blackened, grilled or fried. Cali Style: pickled cabbage, pico, avocado lime sauce & pepperjack cheese. Cartel Style: black bean corn salsa, queso fresco, avocado lime sauce & cilantro

Soups

  • CREAM OF CRAB OR BLEND — $12
  • MARYLAND CRAB — $10

Entrees

  • CHICKEN TENDERS — $18 — Hand battered and served with hand cut fries and cole slaw
  • FRIED SHRIMP — $25 — Hand battered and served with hand cut fries and cole slaw
  • FISH & CHIPS — $22 — 8oz Beer battered cod served with hand cut fries and cole slaw
  • CRAB CAKE — MKT — Baltimore recipe, broiled or fried and served with choice of 2 sides (1 or 2 cakes)
  • TUNA STEAK — $22 — 8oz Blackened or grilled and served with 2 sides
  • OPEN FACE SANDWICH — $18 — 8oz Sliced turkey or roast beef with gravy and served with mashed potatoes & choice of side
  • THE CUP’S POKE BOWL — $20 — 8oz Lightly blackened, diced, rare ahi tuna, avocado, cucumber, spicy mayo, sesame seeds, cilantro lime rice, and scallions
  • CATCH OF THE DAY — MKT
  • BUTCHER’S CUT — MKT

Handhelds

Served with our house pasta salad. Add hand cut fries for $2 or onion rings for $3. Wrap it up for an extra $2.

  • CRAB CAKE — MKT — Served with lettuce & tomato
  • BIG CHEESESTEAK — $18 — 8oz prime beef or chicken topped with Cooper Sharp and served with choice of toppings
  • TUNA STEAK — $18 — 8oz ahi tuna, seared or blackened with lettuce, tomato & side of Cusabi
  • FRENCH DIP — $18 — 8oz sliced Angus beef on a sub roll topped with provolone & served with au jus and hand cut fries
  • SHRIMP SALAD — $17 — 8oz Baltimore style with lettuce & tomato
  • GOING BACK TO CALI WRAP — $15 — 8oz Sliced turkey, bacon & avocado
  • BUFFALO CHICKEN WRAP — $15 — Tenders tossed in buffalo sauce, with lettuce, tomatoes and bleu cheese dressing
  • ROCK — $17 — 8oz Beer battered rockfish with lettuce & tomato
  • BURGER YOUR WAY — $16 — 8oz patty with lettuce & tomato
  • CHICKEN SANDWICH — $16 — 8oz breast with lettuce & tomato

Salads

  • CAESAR SALAD — $13
  • GARDEN SALAD — $12 — Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions & green peppers
  • THE CUP’S COBB SALAD — $20 — Garden salad topped with grilled chicken, bacon, bleu cheese crumbles, avocado, egg and topped with honey mustard pretzel crumbles
  • CHEF SALAD — $20 — Lettuce, diced chicken breast, turkey, shredded cheddar, egg, tomatoes, cucumbers and avocado

Add Ons

Grilled Chicken Breast $6 | Chicken Tenders $6 | Grilled or Fried Shrimp $10 | Shrimp Salad $10 | Ahi Tuna $10 | Mahi $10 | Crab Cake MKT

Sides

  • COLE SLAW — $4
  • MASHED POTATOES — $4
  • PASTA SALAD — $4
  • VEGE OF THE DAY — $5
  • GREEN BEANS — $5
  • HAND-CUT FRIES — $5
  • ONION RINGS — $5

Happy Hour Hours

Monday – Saturday: Open – 6PM | Sunday: All Day

  • NATTY LIGHT — $2
  • DOMESTIC BOTTLES & CANS — $4
  • ALL OTHER BOTTLES & CANS — $5
  • DOMESTIC DRAFTS — $4
  • CRAFT DRAFTS — $5
  • NEW AMSTERDAM CRUSHES — $6
  • TITO’S, TANQUERAY, CAPTAIN MORGAN, EL JIMADOR & JACK DANIELS MX — $6
  • RAILS — $4 — One mixer
  • BEACH BOMBS — $5 — Grape, Cherry & Orange
  • WINE BY THE GLASS — $2 OFF

Stop by for great food, cold drinks, and weekly entertainment at The Rusty Cup Bar and Grill.

Call Now

Follow us for updates

302-402-6693

699 Bethany Loop #1, Bethany Beach, DE 19930